Updated 18 March: The PM’s contemplation of whether she would have the votes to get her deal through the House of Commons on the third attempt or whether to pull it a second time has met the immovable object of Erskine May, the Parliamentary rulebook. This has been interpreted by the Speaker, John Bercow, as clearly ruling out an attempt to force a vote through more than once when the substance of the matter has not changed, or not changed substantially.

The Government is furious but is stuck between a rock and a hard place. The rock is the British Parliament, which now will not allow the Conservative Government to hold it in contempt (it has been found to have done so once only recently, and still over Brexit). The hard place is the EU, co-signatory to May’s Withdrawal Agreement. They are due to hold an EU summit on Thursday to discuss the “current situation”, arrangements which were made before the Speaker’s latest ruling which will no doubt be seen to complicate things even further.

May has been instructed by the success of her Government’s own motion last week to request a delay from the EU. Whether Bercow will see such a delay “substantially changes” the deal is another matter, and that anyway begs the question of whether the EU will grant one of more than a couple of months with European elections looming, and a grant of one less than a couple of months allows very little time for the UK to get anything sorted out.

And so, at this moment, the possible scenarios are that May will request a delay and present a renewed deal to the Commons with the Speaker agreeing to or rejecting the changes as “substantial”; if she does and he agrees, this will result in the deal being put to Parliament again. Otherwise not.  The Government could also prorrogue Parliament: this would almost certainly require the Queen to agree to a Government request to terminate this current session of Parliament and start another. This would allow Meaningful Vote 3 to take place because the rule is just that a defeated vote cannot be put back to Parliament unchanged within the same session.

Alternatively, the EU could grant an extension purely for an election, or a second referendum … or MV3 could be brought back with an approval referendum as an adjunct so that even if Parliament were to approve the Withdrawal Agreement, it would still have to be put to the country to approve. Whether that would be considered “substantial change” would also need to be determined. And of course, this all assumes EU agreement to a request for delay.

The speaker clearly chooses his moments for maximum impact. And the impact is, currently, maximum, at least in terms of confusion. And as things stand right now, the UK is set to leave the EU at 11pm in 11 days time.

Source Janet Anscombe: https://www.janetanscombe.com/news/brexit-negotiations-affecting-british-nationals-in-tenerife.html

XVII Subida Arona-La Escalona rally 18-19 October

XVII Subida Arona-La Escalona rally 18-19 October

  Photo: Rallymotor2000. Arona Ayuntamiento’s tourism and sports departments have announced the 17th Subida Arona – La Escalona rally will be held this coming weekend, 18 and 19 October. The race, organized by Escudería Zapatera Sport Arona, contributes to the...

La Laguna Noche en Blanco 2019

La Laguna Noche en Blanco 2019

    Photo: Turismo. It’s now an established annual event in the run up to Christmas that attracts people to La Laguna in their hundreds of thousands, and this year’s Noche en Blanco will take place on Saturday 16 November. The previous occasions have been enormous...

Carnaval 2020

Carnaval 2020

Once again we’re looking ahead to Carnaval, with the poster unveiled tonight for Santa Cruz 2020. It’s this one, designed by Javier Nóbrega, for a carnival based on the theme of the Flirty Fifties (Los Coquetos Años 50). The poster was commissioned this year, rather...

Advertisements

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This